When I first saw this video for Southern Living's four-ingredient peanut butter cookies, I couldn't conceal my skepticism. How could you possibly make cookies from peanut butter, egg, sugar, and vanilla extract alone?! It seemed suspiciously too easy, but I had to try it out! With so many friends and family members on gluten-free and dairy-free diets, I figured if the recipe did work, I could make a lot of people happy.
Best Ever Peanut Butter Cookies I was thrilled when I found this recipe and was completely satisfied after trying it. I've been disappointed with most peanut butter cookie recipes I've tried in the past-always resulting in a thin, crispy cookie. I love a thick, softer cookie. The addition of both peanut butter chips and chocolate chips makes these even better! You won't be disappointed.