This could work with the story of the wise men and the star leading them to baby Jesus. These stars look easy with craft sticks, glue and glitter. You could use a verse from the Jesus story.OR for Abraham stars for the wall!
I used paint chips from the hardware store as a border on top of black bulletin board paper. I hand-lettered the verse using a chalk own! People have to look very closely to realize it's not a real chalkboard. Could be good for VBS daily Bible Points