Butter making and other pioneer day ideas... I remember doing this at vacation bible school before it was all big boxed theme curriculum purchased for complete lack of imagination and commitment of the congregation.
Pioneer Day craft - make a mini quilt! Let the kids pick what they want from your scrap fabric, cut squares, sew together, use a bit of fleece for the back. I let my kids do this, my daughter's is pinks and reds and butterflys, my son's is blues, blacks, some snoopy fabric, and red. You also have the option of stuffing them to make little pillows!