Tortuga Gorda Cocktail This fruity tropical island drink packs quite a punch with 4 types of liquor. 1 oz. Cruzan 151 rum 1 oz. pineapple rum 1 oz. blue Curaçao 1 oz. melon liqueur 1 oz. each of pineapple juice and orange juice 1 oz. Sprite 1. Mix in a big glass with ice. Stir, then garnish with an orange and a cherry.