Discover all the things that inspire you
You can also sign in with

You might also like pins from these topics





There's more Recipe Pins to see...
Come take a look at what else is here!
She used Pinterest to roll her first pasta
Join Pinterest to discover all the things that inspire you.
Creating an account means you’re okay with Pinterest's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
billion Pins
to explore
seconds to
sign up (free!)
Visit site

Sumbitch Cookies

Vegetarian • Makes 36 cookies


2 Eggs


1 cup Peanut butter cups

Baking & Spices

2 cups All-purpose flour
1 tsp Baking soda
3/4 cup Brown sugar, dark
1 cup Chocolate caramels
1 cup Chocolate chips, semisweet
1 tsp Salt
3/4 cup Sugar
1 tsp Vanilla extract, store-bought or homemade

Oils & Vinegars

1 Oil spray, Nonstick


1 cup Butter, unsalted


1 tsp Water
  • Jamie Schubert

    Make HIMYM's Sumbitch Cookies: Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Caramel Cookies

  • Jillian Hertel

    HIMYM's Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Caramel Sumbitch Cookies Recipe

Related Pins

How I Met Your Mother "Suit Up!" Wine Glass.... So need to get this for Aaron.

Suit Up - How I Met Your Mother Keychain

How often do you get them chance to pick up a sledgehammer And bash them living hell out of it?

Emily Buchanan

Swirled Sugar Cookies... Every Holiday Color!! Would be fun in orange and black for halloween or green and purple!

How I Met Your Mother's Sumbitch Cookies Recipe | Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Caramel | Eat the Trend

Christmas Sugar Cookies & Sugar Cookie Tips ! by pastryaffair, via Flickr

Chocolate Peanut Butter Truffle Cookies are a chocolate peanut butter cookie and they're filled with a peanut butter chocolate truffle!

Whether you’re looking for a holiday cookie recipe for an upcoming party, or you just feel like eating your feelings – I promise you, Pumpkin Cookies are the way to go! (eating my feelings...)

Cookies made to look like @OPI_PRODUCTS nail polish bottles! :)