Discover and save creative ideas
    Related Pins

    Sumbitch Cookies

    Vegetarian • Makes 36 cookies


    2 Eggs


    1 cup Peanut butter cups

    Baking & Spices

    2 cups All-purpose flour
    1 tsp Baking soda
    3/4 cup Brown sugar, dark
    1 cup Chocolate caramels
    1 cup Chocolate chips, semisweet
    1 tsp Salt
    3/4 cup Sugar
    1 tsp Vanilla extract, store-bought or homemade

    Oils & Vinegars

    1 Oil spray, Nonstick


    1 cup Butter, unsalted


    1 tsp Water
    • Angie Kachelmeier

      Make HIMYM's Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Caramel Sumbitch Cookies | Shine Food - Yahoo Shine

    • Jamie Schubert

      Make HIMYM's Sumbitch Cookies: Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Caramel Cookies

    • Jillian Hertel

      HIMYM's Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Caramel Sumbitch Cookies Recipe

    More from this board

    These s'mores baked doughnuts are going to be your new favorite thing to wake up to. They share all of the elements of the childhood favorite without stoking a campfire or deep-frying. Watch the video to see how easy they are to make.

    Skip the checkout line and make these Almond Joys and Mounds at home.

    There's a whole wide world of creative pie-inspired desserts out there, ranging from deep-fried hand pies to pumpkin pie dip to clever, time-saving pie bars. Keep reading for 14 creative ideas.

    This Japanese dessert has two Kit Kats baked into a flaky croissant and topped with powdered sugar. While you may not be able to venture to Japan anytime soon, we took the liberty of re-creating this insanely delicious-looking hybrid using Kit Kats and crescent dough.

    Most will admit that cookie dough is the best (if only) reason for making cookies, but these incredible cookie dough truffles from The Cookie Dough Lover's Cookbook skip the whole nonsensical baking part.

    You're only two minutes away from deliciousness.

    The shandy, a classic British cocktail of beer and lemonade, soda or ginger beer, is one of the most refreshing drinks out there. Pour it into a popsicle mold and you have the perfect antidote to sweltering Summer weather.

    This recipe deviates only a little from the original Toll House one. The main differences include the salt factor and the type of chocolate I'm using. If salty-sweet desserts aren't your thing, don't worry! Just use unsalted butter and forgo the flakes. However, if you're open to an experiment, you'll find that the salt enhances the caramel-chocolate flavors. Yum!

    Whether you're on a gluten-free diet or just looking to expand your baking repertoire, flourless cakes are a category of dessert absolutely worth exploring. Keep reading for our top picks, including a light-as-air chocolate cloud cake, its ultrarich chocolate-cardamom cousin, and even a few nonchocolate options like a melt-in-your-mouth lemon ricotta almond cake.

    Some of the most creative and inventive recipes on the web start with a box of cake mix. Whether chocolate waffles or Funfetti Rice Krispies treats, one of these cake mix desserts will inspire you to throw on an apron and head to the kitchen.

    Here we've rounded up 15 all-American sweets, plus two clever spins (think sugar cookie butter and chocolate chip cookie dough truffles) on each. Have fun figuring out which over-the-top treat to try first!

    Fall is that time of year where everyone and their mothers are trying to come up with new ways to incorporate pumpkin spice into their products. While many are good enough to consume year round, others are a bit of a reach. So you don't have to eat your way through to find out which is which, here's a ranking of PSL products from this season.

    These pillowy pumpkin cupcakes let you enjoy the taste of Fall without feeling sick afterward. The batter, which bakes up into the fluffiest, lightest cupcakes I've ever tried, is made from whipped egg whites and has a slight tang from the addition of sour cream.

    Here's a round up of homemade recipes for store-bought candies that are fun and fulfilling to make as well as pretty darn impressive and tasty. Keep reading to find a DIY version of your guilty pleasure treat.

    Take the butter-rich, chewy texture of blondies and marry it with cake-batter flavor and a near-absurd amount of rainbow sprinkles, and you have these ridiculously delicious bars. Seriously, drop everything and make these tonight — they're expletive-inducing good.

    Pie crust has a reputation for being difficult to make. That reputation isn't necessarily the case though. Try this butter rich recipe and find that it's not quite as daunting as you might have thought.

    Let's be real: the best part about baking cookies is eating the raw cookie dough. (Eating warm, fresh-from-the-oven cookies is a close second.) With this recipe you can eat all the dough you like without fearing the uncooked egg.

    You wouldn't be able to tell from the weather, but Fall is right around the corner, and that means eating delicious apples every day (not just to keep the doctor away). You've always loved hot apple cider and baked apples, but it's quite possible that one of these recipes is about to become your new go-to.

    Mini Salted Caramel Chocolate Pies (via My Life, Blogged.) #POPSUGARSelect

    From caramel-glazed to s'more-flavored, here are 16 pumpkin cupcake recipes that will last you throughout the Fall season and beyond. We hope you're not sick of pumpkin yet because there's a lot of it heading your way. Start baking!

    If time is truly of the essence, pick up a chocolate bar at the store; when you have a bit more wiggle room, you can do no better than these 30-plus easy, chocolate-rich recipes.

    Cookie Butter Rice Krispies Treat Engagement Rings — great for a bridal shower, or cut them into squares for other occasions, via Erica Sweet Tooth

    Snickerdoodle-inspired smoothie recipe (oats + cinnamon + chia seeds + vanilla + almond milk + bananas), plus 4 more dessert-inspired "junk food" smoothies from Claire Thomas

    Like Recess? Then you'll love these DIY chocolate peanut butter bars, courtesy of Jaclyn {Cooking Classy}