Visit site
  • Amy Pilgrim

    thick, soft sugar cookie recipe (buttercream frosting recipe too)-- This recipe is, in my opinion, THE BEST sugar cookie recipe out there. I think the sour cream and the short baking time are what makes them soft, chewy and just perfect!

  • Kylie Stewart

    Peppermint Plum: {Thick, Soft Sugar Cookies} I made this yesterday and it is my new sugar cookie recipe. It tastes great, is super easy, and they really are very soft. If using intricate cookie cutters (or say, stars with long arms), a studier recipe might be better, but for general shapes this was fine and super delicious. Also included is a new buttercream frosting recipe. It tasted about as good as regular buttercream.

  • Cheryl Tice

    Thick Soft Sugar Cookies... my sweet tooth is acting up...

Related Pins

Soft Frosted Sugar Cookies. I don't know why I didn't pin this before. They're suuuper tasty.

These Soft Amish Sugar Cookies are hands-down my new favorite cookie. So simple and melt-in-your-mouth delicious I can’t even stand it!

PILLOWY SOFT SUGAR COOKIES 1c. butter; 2c. sugar; 2 eggs; 3t. vanilla; 1c. sour cream; 1t. salt; 2t. soda; 5 1/2c. flour: Cream butter & sugar, add eggs & vanilla, then sour cream. Combine dry and mix in. Roll 1/4-1/3" thick. Bake on parchment 7-8min@375. Will look underdone. Cool 5min, remove from parchment. ICING: 1/2c. butter; 4c. 10x sugar; 2t. vanilla; 1/4-1/3c. milk.

Sugar Cookies - this dough is SO hard to work with. The cookies are VERY fluffy when cooked. Sort of pillow fluffy. If you like that sort of thing, you could try these. But this is not what I expect in a cut-out sugar cookie. They taste fine, but won't be making them again.

Lofthouse Style Soft Sugar Cookies from twopeasandtheirpo...! Love these super soft sugar cookies!

Angel Sugar Cookies-Ree Drummond / The Pioneer Woman, via Flickr: These cookies are so easy and so good.