Maybe not a store-bought toy, but cootie catchers were still super popular in school. You could find out who you were going to marry or what your future career was going to be, all decided by your best friend or classmate. X-D Games, 90S Kids, Remember This, Fortune Teller, Cootie Catchers, Childhood Memories, Colors, Grand Kids, Schools Fun
Also on these boards
Scotch Hair Tape. Cheryl Tiegs. I remember this product. We used it for that required little curl at the temples.