There’s more to see...
Come take a look at what else is here!
He used Pinterest to start his collection
Join Pinterest to discover all the things that inspire you.
Creating an account means you’re okay with Pinterest's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
billion Pins
to explore
seconds to
sign up (free!)
Visit site

Pilgrim Hat Cookies

1 hr to make


32 Peanut butter cups, miniature

Baking & Spices

7 drops Food coloring, yellow
1 cup Vanilla frosting


1 package Fudge-striped cookies


32 pieces Orange mini chiclets gum
  • Kimberly Smith

    Pilgrim Hat Cookies Recipe- cool idea for thanksgiving

  • Mary Eliza Hendricks

    Pilgrim Hat Cookies ~ Thanksgiving Ingredients: 1 cup vanilla frosting 7 drops yellow food coloring 32 miniature peanut butter cups 1 package (11-1/2 ounces) fudge-striped cookies 32 pieces orange mini Chiclets gum

  • Joanne Kaplan

    Top 10 Thanksgiving Recipes

  • LC Pals

    A classic Thanksgiving treat. Pilgrim Hat Cookies

  • Rachael Klotzberger

    Pilgrim Hat Cookies! Happy Holidays!!!!

Related Pins

Pilgrim Hat Cookies: I 1st found this recipe about 5 years ago in one of those 5" x 7" cookbooks you see at the checkout line in a grocery store. I made them with my daughter to bring to grandma's house for Thanksgiving dinner. Recipes like this are a great way to introduce your kids to cooking and following recipes. They're cute, the kids get a kick out of them and they taste good.

Turkey Pilgrim Cookies 84 pieces candy corn 24 double-stuffed Oreo cookies 3/4 cup canned chocolate frosting 12 miniature peanut butter cups 12 Hershey Kisses of your choice 3/4 cup canned vanilla frosting Orange food coloring 6 miniature marshmallows, halved 6 mini Oreo cookies 12 Rolo candies

Thanksgiving treat: Pilgrim Hat Cookies (easy), and cute for the kids. :)

Perfect Treat of Fall and Thanksgiving - Fun for the Whole Family to Make - Pilgrim Hat Cookies Recipe

How cute are these? Chocolate wafer cookies, Reese's PB cups, and orange icing; what could be simpler?

For a Thanksgiving snack

Perfect kid food craft for Thanksgiving- Pilgrim hat cookies. Handmade in the Heartland