Visit site

Pilgrim Hat Cookies

1 hr to make


32 Peanut butter cups, miniature

Baking & Spices

7 drops Food coloring, yellow
1 cup Vanilla frosting


1 package Fudge-striped cookies


32 pieces Orange mini chiclets gum
  • D.J.

    Thanksgiving treats including: Pilgrim Hat Cookies

  • Joanne Kaplan

    Top 10 Thanksgiving Recipes

  • Homeschooled Kids Online

    Pilgrim Hat Cookies - Cute Idea for a Kid's Thanksgiving Party

  • Nicki Waltman

    Pilgrim Hat Cookies ~ Thanksgiving Ingredients: 1 cup vanilla frosting 7 drops yellow food coloring 32 miniature peanut butter cups 1 package (11-1/2 ounces) fudge-striped cookies 32 pieces orange mini Chiclets gum

  • Brianne Hamstra

    Pilgrim Hat Cookies! Happy Holidays!!!!

Related Pins

Pilgrim Hat Cookies: I 1st found this recipe about 5 years ago in one of those 5" x 7" cookbooks you see at the checkout line in a grocery store. I made them with my daughter to bring to grandma's house for Thanksgiving dinner. Recipes like this are a great way to introduce your kids to cooking and following recipes. They're cute, the kids get a kick out of them and they taste good.

The kids had so much fun making "witch" hats for halloween, these will be perfect and easy for Thanksgiving - may try some with chocolate covered cherries if I can find them

Turkey Pilgrim Cookies 84 pieces candy corn 24 double-stuffed Oreo cookies 3/4 cup canned chocolate frosting 12 miniature peanut butter cups 12 Hershey Kisses of your choice 3/4 cup canned vanilla frosting Orange food coloring 6 miniature marshmallows, halved 6 mini Oreo cookies 12 Rolo candies

Perfect Treat of Fall and Thanksgiving - Fun for the Whole Family to Make - Pilgrim Hat Cookies Recipe

Thanksgiving Pilgram hats: Reeses peanut butter cup, chocolate wafer cookie, piping icing.

Pilgrim Hats ... fudge striped cookies, mini peanut butter cup, fruit roll-up, chocolate icing as glue

Pilgrim Hat Cookies. Not very healthy, but they sure look cute! from craftily-ever-aft...