Apple Cheddar Pie - Church Potluck Dessert This is my VERY FAVORITE APPLE PIE. Loaded inside and on top with 3/4 cup of Sharp Cheddar Cheese. That extra sharp snap of the cheese combines with the sweet seasoned cook apples to make a Wisconsin treat. I even added my Mother in Law's Old School never fail Flakey lard Crust Recipe!!! THE BEST!