Cowboy/Hotel Butter on Steak. I grilled my steaks with salt and pepper. 3/4 cup softened, salted butter. Half a clove of garlic finely minced. A handful of parsley finely minced. A squirch of lemon juice. A dash of red pepper and a touch of black pepper... I think that's all I put in my impromptu version. Served with wedge salad and baked potatoes with broccoli and cheddar sauce. Perhaps a roll would have been nice.