There’s more to see...
Sign up to discover and save different things to try in 2015.
Visit Site
  • Erika Lynn

    Pilgrim Hat #Cookies - Try this simple recipe. #Thanksgiving #desserts

  • Wendy Brawn

    Pilgrim+Hat+Cookies | Pilgrim Hat Cookies | Holiday Ideas

  • Sunshine Peterson

    Pilgrim hat cookies! Cute and creative Thanksgiving treat idea!

  • HeidiSongs

    Top 10 Thanksgiving Cookie Treat Recipes: Pilgrim Hat Cookies!!!! Ba ha!

  • Holly Frazier

    Pilgrim hat cookies made with mini peanut butter cups and Keebler fudge stripes.

  • Rachel Pennington Smith

    LOVED them! Pilgrim Hat Cookies. Super easy to make. I used vanilla icing with a few drops of yellow food coloring to push my Reese's cups down onto the fudge cookie, and for the buckle I used Reese's pieces. Everyone loved them. :)

Related Pins

Hostess with the Mostess® - Fall or Thanksgiving Harvest Collection Photoshoot

{Thanksgiving Treats} We've tried 1, 2 & 4. Can't wait to try the others this year. Always a fun activity to do with the kids

How cute are these? Chocolate wafer cookies, Reese's PB cups, and orange icing; what could be simpler?

Pilgrim Hat cupcakes for Thanksgiving. See MORE Pilgrim themed cupcakes and other Thanksgiving themed cupcakes at

Cute Pilgrims! We have a Real Deals in Pueblo now!!

Pilgrim hat cookies ...we've done this with chocolate dipped marshmallows but I like this better ... Could use Rolos instead of Reese's Cups for nut allergies

thanksgiving cookies

Thanksgiving Pilgrim Hat Cookies by Oh So Savvy Mom.

Candy turkey. Stick candy corn into the center of one oreo for feathers, and using icing, glue that oreo (with the feathers on top) to another oreo. Stick on a reeses peanut butter cup (with a slice taken off so it sits right), a whopper (for his head), and the white tip of a candy corn (for his nose). Using colored icing add eyes, a gobbler, and feet.

  • Cindy Russ

    Made these a couple of years ago. They came out really cute!