Sink a Ship pirate party game! My mom made the pirate ship on a poster board for me and I cut the holes and got little bean bags for cannon balls. The kids had fun throwing the 'cannon balls' to sink the ship and earn gold dabloons!
Pirate Ship Battle While doing some Pirate-y research one day, I happened upon one fabulous idea over at Party Planning Mom. She made two large cardboard pirate ships and had a game involving paper canon balls.